Most personal injury cases are resolved through settlements. However, there are times when going to trial is the best way to ensure justice for the injured party. Understanding when a case might need to go to trial can help you make informed decisions and protect your rights.
Why Some Cases Don’t Settle
Insurance companies often try to settle claims quickly to minimize their payouts. While many cases can be resolved this way, certain situations make a fair settlement difficult or impossible:
- Disputed liability: The insurance company denies responsibility or argues that the accident was not their client’s fault.
- Underestimated damages: Insurance adjusters may undervalue medical bills, lost income, or long-term pain and suffering.
- Refusal to negotiate: In some instances, insurers may refuse to offer a reasonable settlement, forcing the injured party to pursue legal action.
When these issues arise, settlement negotiations may reach a standstill. That’s when filing a lawsuit and preparing for trial becomes necessary.
Signs Your Case May Go to Trial
Every case is unique, but there are common factors that suggest a trial may be needed:
- Complex or severe injuries: Cases involving catastrophic injuries, permanent disability, or prolonged medical treatment may require a trial to fully reflect the damages.
- Disputed liability or conflicting evidence: If fault is contested, a trial allows a jury to evaluate the evidence and determine who is responsible.
- Inadequate settlement offers: When the insurance company refuses to offer fair compensation, a trial may be the only way to secure justice.
- Multiple parties involved: Cases with more than one responsible party or complex liability issues may need a trial for proper resolution.
An experienced personal injury attorney can evaluate your case, explain your options, and determine whether pursuing a trial is the most effective strategy.
How an Attorney Prepares a Case for Trial
Going to trial requires careful preparation and strategy. Attorneys will:
- Gather and organize evidence, including medical records, witness statements, and accident reports.
- Consult experts to provide testimony on the extent of injuries and damages.
- Develop a compelling case to present before a judge or jury.
- Negotiate with the opposing party, both before and during trial, to maximize the potential outcome.
Even if a case goes to trial, attorneys often continue settlement discussions to resolve the matter before the courtroom verdict is rendered.
St. Louis Personal Injury Attorneys
Not all personal injury cases need to go to trial, but knowing when it might be necessary is key to protecting your rights and receiving fair compensation. When insurance companies deny responsibility, undervalue your claim, or refuse to negotiate, a trial may be the best course of action.
If you’ve been injured in St. Louis, Columbia, or elsewhere in Missouri, Meyerkord Law Group can review your case and guide you through your options. Contact us today at (314) 500-6000 for a complimentary consultation — we are committed to prioritizing your injury and advocating for the justice you deserve.